23 Comments

When I was master, we blocked off all the light coming into the lodge and created a moment of reflection before opening. Only did it once and I'm not too sure how it was received but I thought that a little time with no distraction on our roles in Masonry would be good. For many years my lodge in Ilwaco used candles at the alter. Enjoyed the little bit of extra time watching them get lit, instead of "click" there they are!

I've also always thought that degrees should be done in costume. Especially the 3rd. Feel it would add to the experience for the brother being brought to light.

Expand full comment

Olympia Lodge No. 1 had been doing every MM degree in costume ever since I could remember. It’s always an honor to play ANY part in the degree. Centralia had been doing it, using York Rite costumes, for about 15 years, and still they do it today. There are some Lodges that resist using the costumes, thinking it takes too much time to put them on and take them off, and runs the meeting too late. No surprise, those Lodges aren’t doing too well.

In Centralia, we also do the Second Section of the Fellowcraft degree (Middle Chamber) in costume. Just the SD (the lecturer), and the 3 principal officers. That’s been about 11 years, and is a firm tradition now in the Lodge. Using a lantern and very limited lighting for this section is a new idea that has been very well-received, and might become a new innovation in this ceremony.

Expand full comment

>>"There are some Lodges that resist using the costumes, thinking it takes too much time >>to put them on and take them off, and runs the meeting too late. No surprise, those >>Lodges aren’t doing too well."

I am perpetually amazed at how some Lodges are so unwilling to see the connection between unwillingness to make things interesting and the fact that they are not thriving.

Expand full comment

I really like the idea of creating a moment of reflection prior to the start of the meeting. I think that contemplation prior to the ritual must serve to enhance it. I do think that guys can get uncomfortable with change the first time or two, especially when it involves matters of the spirit, but then they grow to like the changes.

I believe that most, if not all York Rite bodies had costumes, and given that so many have consolidated, I imagine that there are lots of costumes available for our Lodges, it is just a matter of finding them.

Expand full comment

While I would love to go back to real candles, we are but renters. There was something to having to light the real deal.

And not just "flicking a Bic" to light them. Use a taper and extinguish them with snuffer.

Using incense during the 3rd Degree drama would add even more when costumes are worn. Bringing the candidate even more into the time period of the drama.

Expand full comment

I've always loved incense, and wish that more Lodges could bring it in, especially for Degrees. I really wanted to do so when I was Master, but our Temple in Centralia has serious commercial fire prevention equipment, with a censor right above the altar. I was always afraid that I'd end up setting the system off. If it wasn't for that, we would have used it.

Expand full comment

Yes to all. I hate the electric candles. I don't mind electric lighting for the room in general, but the three great lights should be natural. Dimmable spot lights for the altar and wardens stations would be okay. Illumination for the entire lodge should only be for cleaning purposes. Of course, the lodge I am trying to create will not have a permanent location except a small study for intimate gatherings and reflections and a place to store our equipment. Outdoor lodges with torches will be common. We can also rent spaces from churches other fraternities and restaurants. Bringing the atmosphere with us to these spaces may be the hardest part of a nomadic lodge.

Expand full comment

There is a great deal to be said for holding Degrees, and even Lodge outdoors. More of our Lodges should do it. I think that the massive turnout for the outdoor First Degree at Quilcene, the Seconds at Roche Harbor, and Granite Falls, and the Third at Granite Falls show how much Masons enjoy doing that, either in daylight, or under torchlight.

Expand full comment

Every Master Mason should know and remember how Exodus 3:5 (KJV)

"And he said, Draw not nigh hither: put off thy shoes from off thy feet, for the place whereon thou standest is holy ground." applies to the 3rd Degree.

This is also referred to in Acts 7:33

"Then said the Lord to him, Put off thy shoes from thy feet: for the place where thou standest is holy ground."

Every Master Mason after learning this lesson can wear shoes as the Lodge remains or at least should remain Holy Ground in his heart.

When I was Master of Centralia Lodge we reduced the size of the Lodge by moving the SW station and JD place to the center of the Lodge and the JW station halfway up the south wall. Not only did it create a more personal interaction among the Brothers but made it easier to hear each other.

When I was installed in Tenino Lodge it was by electronic candlelight. Everyone enjoyed it except for the Photographer LOL It was not the easiest Photography challenge. Never did get any pictures from her.

When we had Phil Rice come down for his talk as Ben Franklin, I talked to the pastor of a church I was going to the time and he let me have all the candles left over from the Christmas eve candlelight service and we heard Ben Franklin with everyone holding a candle. It was a night few will ever forget.

Expand full comment

I really like the idea of condensing the size of the Lodge when we have much more space than men. As you say, interactions are better, and it is much easier for everyone to hear.

>>"we heard Ben Franklin with everyone holding a candle. It was a night few will ever forget."

And I think this is key. Creating great experiences such as this are exactly what we need to do. If we can create nights that our Masons will never forget often enough, we will never have to worry about the future of our Lodge, for we will know it to be bright.

Expand full comment

I believe that anything we can do to create a 'liminal space' would be a good thing. Our everyday world too often creeps into the Lodge room, and things like candles and incense, and soothing music can shift our brain states and allow emotional space for more spiritual thoughts and experiences. I have often thought that we could start the ritual with the harsh neon lights on, and then as the ritual progresses change the lighting to be dominated by candles, so that our senses experience a change in our ritual space that is coordinated with the ritual. Make the opening ritual an active transition, from ordinary space to spiritual space, and then reverse the process in the closing ritual, so that when the ritual is over we are back in "normal space".

Expand full comment

What an awesome and interesting idea! Thank you for sharing it.

I sincerely hope that a Lodge will see this post and decide to give it a try, I'd love to see it. I'll see if maybe I can convince my home Lodge Sultan-Monroe to experiment with it. The building there might be perfect for it, as there are backlit stained glass panels in the East, West, and South. I could see the lights slowly fading away until all that remained were the altar candles, and these three stained glass panels.

Expand full comment

That sounds beautiful and moving. When I imagine it I it reminds me of lots of moving experiences I have had, and the calming effect it has had on me, sunset at the beach, midnight mass, my time in a zen monastery. Our brains just seem to understand as the lights fad the world changes. Thanks for the reply, and let me know how it works out.

Expand full comment

I think it will be very nice. The stained glass panels all show the sun at the appropriate height to the station, and they are very gently, not brightly lit.

What I don't remember, as it has been so long since I've sat in that Lodge room is if the ceiling lights are on dimmers. I think that will be necessary, but of course also an easy retrofit if needed.

Thank you again for providing this idea, I think it is quite superb.

Expand full comment

I’m going to start by dumping rain on the parade, but hear me out, I’ll bring out a LOT of sunshine afterwards.

From experience, unfortunately I’ve found that candles and ceiling fans are a bad combination, and on certain days in the summer, those ceiling fans sure are nice! So there might have to be a compromise in that case, if your Lodge has ceiling fans or other forced-air climate control that might make the candles burn down too fast. As for the incense, again unfortunately, we have several Brothers who have COPD that have bad reactions to incense. It was another item that we tried and had to abandon; our Brother’s health is very important. Many of our Lodge rooms are more like large conference rooms than a place to hold a “sacred Retreat of Friendship and Virtue,” which could present a challenge to create the ambient lighting to give a good degree justice. And sadly, one of the worst bouts of rain I douse on this parade is the resistance I’ve received from the older Brethren that grumble about the diminished lighting, goofy costumes, Lectures that are given by more than one person, and other innovations that differ from what they’ve seen over the last few decades. You know the drill. “That’s the way we’ve always done it.”

Now, for the sunshine.

Not all Lodges have the ceiling fans; they might have heat pumps, or you can arrange your fans to save the candles. You might be able to give due notice about the use of incense, or open more windows to bring in fresh air along with the incense. Sure, many Lodges meet in bland boxes for rooms, but there are at least a few (including a Lodge that a frequent contributor to Emeth is an member) that have taken their “bland boxes” and turned them in to excellent Lodge rooms. Centralia Lodge is fortunate that it is one of the most “Masonic” Lodge rooms in the Jurisdiction, featuring many references to our ritual in its furnishings. But it shows that your Lodge can take the initiative and make a difference in your Lodge’s atmosphere. And it can be a team effort as well!

Lastly, about those old curmudgeons. That’s okay. Find out who else is interested in doing the candlelight ceremonies, the costume degrees, and similar ideas. Form a team. Put it together and DO a costume degree with those who are on board with your idea. Practice, and give an truly impressive performance. Then at the Festive Board, ask the candidate of his impressions of the degree that he just experienced. Trust me, NOBODY is going to grumble about it again. It might take a few degrees to do it, but I know first hand that not only those curmudgeons will change their outlook on the situation, but they’ll then see that as the “tradition.” One time we were doing a Fellowcraft degree, and I “forgot” on purpose to grab the costumes for the Middle Chamber Lecture, just to see what response I’d get, if any. I was pleased to hear from not only the younger Masons, but also many of the older members: “Hey, Very Worshipful! Where’s the costumes? I thought we were going to do this in Costume!!!” And they’d go to the closet and get them out on their own! I was very pleased. We have now also added different lighting for the Middle Chamber Lecture, which is an adaptation of the atmosphere of an outdoor Torchlight degree, only indoors. It also was very well received, and will likely become the norm in Centralia lodge.

Before I conclude, I must give due, and proper, recognition to the use of a Lodge Musician. WB Baxter Harwood had been the Musician for several Lodges in District 17 for roughly two decades. His health downturn at the end of 2019, and his passing last year, will bring a silence in our Lodges in the District that hasn’t been experienced in a LONG time. We will have to address this when we open our Lodges back up. Some use “canned” music and run the volume up and down as per the ritual. I’ve done that myself, and while I think we can do better, the “canned” music idea is better than none at all.

We have a clean slate when we re-open our Lodges. There’s a LOT of ideas here in this thread. I strongly encourage the Lodges to print this thread, ALL of these ideas and discuss it in their Lodge meetings.

Expand full comment

I think you are right about the naysayers. The most stubborn resistance comes before the improved experience actually happens. After it gets done a couple of times, they get used to it and start to like it.

Expand full comment

During this past year or so, we’ve been actively remodeling our temple. One of the items is to create a Chamber of Reflection. As I’ve shared previously, I don’t know a lot about the COR other than it’s a sacred place where initiates and candidates can contemplate and pray before receiving the degree. Pre-pandemic, we started making some changes to our degree presentations. We used real candles and turned the lights off. We would then turn the lights on when the Master called for Masonic Light and the initiate’s hoodwink was removed. It was one of the few times I used the “Will and Pleasure of the Master” card and went against the “norm”. I was glad I did. Anytime a sacred space can be created to move us closer to a spiritual experience in lodge, we should do our best to accomplish that.

Expand full comment

“We used real candles and turned the lights off. We would then turn the lights on when the Master called for Masonic Light and the initiate’s hoodwink was removed. It was one of the few times I used the “Will and Pleasure of the Master” card and went against the “norm”. I was glad I did.”

Great! This is something that the Lodges in District 17 have been doing since I joined 25 years ago, likely longer. I’ve actually considered it an essential part of the conferral, even though it’s not noted in the cyphers! I’m glad you made this part of your Lodge’s ritual ceremony.

“One of the items is to create a Chamber of Reflection. As I’ve shared previously, I don’t know a lot about the COR other than it’s a sacred place where initiates and candidates can contemplate and pray before receiving the degree.” One note of caution, again from personal experience. Make sure the Brethren are educated on the purpose of this Chamber. If you don’t, you will receive an incredible amount of resistance, particularly from both the older members, as well as the members of the OES and maybe the youth groups. Usually the resistance is the confusion with the Occult. Tarot cards and the like. I’ve had to address this in two Lodges in my area. But if you can educate the members of the Masonic Family on the COR, you’ll be able to incorporate it into your ceremonies.

Expand full comment

Thank you for your incites and experiences. I’m hoping for positive changes.

Expand full comment

Good point. That is one of the issues that arise from renting to organizations that don't understand Masonic Symbolism.

I do remember a meeting at one point, when the Master invited the appendant bodies in, and those who attended were given a brief and exoteric explanation of our symbolism. As I remember, that was very well received, and I think doing something like that would benefit any Lodge that rents its building to appendant orders.

Expand full comment

Most of the initiates we’ve brought through the COR loved it, understood its significance, and said it greatly enhanced their degree because it put them into the proper state of mind.

But one disliked it, because he immediately thought it satanic and occult based. Since he hasn’t gone through his fc degree, I don’t know if my explanation was sufficient enough to change his mind.

Expand full comment

Interesting.

I would wonder if he would somehow find other parts of Masonry equally objectionable? The Third Degree can be dark, and of course many of our more philosophical authors have historically ranged quite far.

Expand full comment

>>"Anytime a sacred space can be created to move us closer to a spiritual experience in lodge, >>we should do our best to accomplish that."

I think that is exactly correct. Freemasonry is an esoteric, spiritual pursuit, and it is important that we treat it as such.

I don't doubt but that your Lodge will greatly appreciate having the Chamber of Reflection. I know the Lodges in this Jurisdiction that have created and used them, and I know that in every case or at least in almost every case, it has been felt that the COR has been an extremely positive addition.

Expand full comment